I have seen people in Soul Eater get stabbed in the chest and get up. I remember when when Sid knocked Black Star high up into the air, jumped up to him and used a tombstone to slam into his head and send him rocketing into the ground, in which he got up not too long from (I'm aware Black Star is the most durable of the group and that Sid was holding back, but he was still got blasted in the ground). This all never made sense to me. Sid was said to be a much better fighter then Maka and Black Star. I hate that I can't put it well into words and therefore I can't explain why I am confused on the level of power characters in Soul Eater are.
This is important because I don't know if Kid can be hit by real bullets and survive, but all things considered. Kid probably has a better chance at dodging and that's what I reluctantly base my vote on. This is quite debatable on who would win though.