Sigue (Level 8)

I've enjoyed One Piece much better than Fairy Tail. I've found the characters more original and interesting in One Piece, and I also enjoyed the action more. Fairy Tail suffers from terrible villains and the recycled jokes get old very fast. Both anime suffer from the usual problems of the genre, but I found Fairy Tail couldn't really deliver on the action sequences. The little animation whenever they use a power really disrupts the flow of the scenes, which is already pretty bad in the first place. One Piece is the kind of shounen and I don't expect that to change any time soon.