There have been countless titles that I have enjoyed and continue to love that ,if put under formal critique, would be considered horrible. Even if the pacing is bad or the plot is full of holes, I often fall prey to things like cute/charming characters (damn you k-on!) or crazy mindless violence. Even in the 'worst' shows there usually something I can still guiltily enjoy. Honestly,if you were always looking for story telling excellence you would have better luck fine literature and not anime.
I guess the order of which I watch my shows probably wouldn't make much of a difference.