@SMXLR8: Was waiting on GeneralVan to respond.
@GeneralVan: For me, it has more to do with making use of team abilities and battle terrain instead of relying completely on brute force. Ciel's pretty much my major asset in this match thanks to her hax, on top of the island setting being a big problem for Luffy and having more hypersonic fighters on my team (six for me, four for you). If Shana had more speed on her, then I could picture this battle being more problematic for me thanks to her fuzetsu. Otherwise, most of my team could pick her off before she has a chance to set it off.
If you want to continue debating, I have no problem doing so. Otherwise, I think SMXLR8 is expecting both of us to make some sort of decision together on who we think would win this match.