I should point out that this is specifically for new anime episodes and the reviews should be of a certain standard. By that I mean they're written well and stick to a set style. I went with something similar to the Comic Vine reviews in the example I posted. This isn't just a case of posting user reviews on the front page.
@ShadowKnight508: Thanks. Yeah, it would definitely let users know about current anime. I only noticed Squid Girl 2 had started because I follow Crunchyroll on twitter.
@Sparklykiss: Opinion noted! Though I think it would probably be fine to post reviews for each episode in a series. There are only ever a certain amount of shows airing at the same time and we wouldn't cover them all anyway. But we'll see I guess!
@finaldasa: Indeed! As long as articles and reviews are by trusted users we shouldn't have anything bad posted on the front page.
@DocHaus: Awesome, I'd definitely recommend you for this.