
The final tally was:
- Fairy Tail: 3
- One Piece: 6
- School Rumble: 1
So One Piece is the more popular-- but that's not surprising, since the anime has been going on so much longer, while Fairy Tail only just started! The reasons for these votes varied somewhat, although the overall theme was: zomg, One Piece is !@#%ing amazing! vs I Haven't Watched Any One Piece But I Like Fairy Tail! Or as Lan puts it:
"Well, I've only seen bits and pieces (haha) of One Piece, so my vote goes for Fairy Tail because I've actually been watching it (biased I know)! Plus I have a mega girl crush on and worship the awesomeness that is Erza!"
"neither, school rumble is the king of anime comedy"

























I read both Fairy Tail and One Piece. It's series like One Piece is what makes me wish VIZ wasn't such a bastard company that deserved to be put to sleep humanely. Hearing they were putting One Piece into heavy production is the only time I have been even slightly tempted to lift my boycott on all things VIZ. I'm not though.
Fairy Tail is a great read, but it just hasn't ever effected me emotionally on the same level as One Piece has. Many of the moments were just so heartbreaking when you learn about the characters' pasts.
It has so many deeply emotional moments. Like in One Piece Episode 37, in this one Nami things she's lost everything she's been working for. That everyone she loves will die at the hands of Arlong. Out of rage she starts stabbing the Arlong tattoo she had on her shoulder. Luffy shows up and stops her from causing any more harm to herself. Luffy doesn't know anything of what happened to her in the past. She goes from screaming at him to leave to to crying and asking for him help. Luffy just takes his straw hat and places it on her head. Before Luffy would get angry is anyone else so much as touched it. Here he is letting her wear it. Luffy went off to fight Arlong. Luffy didn't even know what Arlong looked like. The only thing he knew was that Arlong made her cry. That was enough reason for him to go kick that guy's fishy ass.
This is just Nami's story. Robin has a tragic past as well. She lost everything in her young life and spent twenty years on the run. She was ready to give her life to save the crew, but Luffy and the others barged in to save her. Everyone Robin had ever known had abandoned her at some point. Luffy and the crew declared war on the World Government just to save her.
That's just how I feel about the matter.
I haven't watched a single episode of either of the animes though.
Oh, and Fairy Tail is pretty good.
Anyway, One Piece vs Fairty Tale, huh. Tbh, I think they resemble each other. One Piece as pirate-type and Fairy Tale as magic-type. They're both good, but I like Fairy Tale more (I'm into Magic and st00f! :3)
We all know Natsu is bad news for fire fist ace, but hey man OP is still beyond Naruto xD
RAVE has a great and heart breaking ending, but in a good way. It's well worth it.
Some of the characters are stocked from there as well, cept for plue
People voted for fairy tale?
What the fuck?
And Some even think that OP is above Bleach as well in battle forums [mmm...]
@Kuro said:
Actually OP has the majority vote here xD
I actually was fallowing that manga series for a while, but had to stop some where around the ending of the mermaid story arc, now i can't remember what volume of on so i decided just not to contunue (this pause was also why i stopped getting manga all together)