FULLMETAL ALCHEMIST #5 - - Watch & Learn

Topic started by No_name_here on Dec. 1, 2012. Last post by ComicMan24 1 year, 11 months ago.
Post by No_name_here (856 posts) See mini bio Level 11
Staff

You know, one of my biggest pet peeves in action-adventures is when the good guys suddenly have a hard time fighting foes that are blatantly below their level (and the level of villains they’ve fought previously) because the plot needs conflict by any means. Yes, the goons on this train have guns and there are hostages around. Yes, the implication is that Mustang set these kids up with a little problem to test them. Still, I don’t buy that Ed & Al couldn’t just snap their fingers and be done with these guys.

This sort of complaint can easily sink into a versus thread diatribe, sure, but it more often arises because an adventure story hasn’t got its own rules straight - - like an anime that’s getting made before its own source material is finished, perhaps?

I remember one of the bigger complaints about BROTHERHOOD was that Hughes didn’t get properly established before he was killed off and we were still expected to be pretty upset about it (Mustang certainly was, anyway). He makes a bigger impression with his debut in this show, certainly, and I expect we’ll be made to care just a little more about him before the Homunculi do him in (if that does actually happen in this version?). Past that, this feels like a kind of needlessly-obfuscating way to get us to Mustang, though.

Both iterations of FMA have had a funny conceit of just presenting both these kids as wunderkinds with prestige that’s well beyond their years - - far enough beyond that even stretches disbelief a little in a show about matter-molding alchemists. BROTHERHOOD got around it by just introducing them at their highest rank first and then just eluding to a number of prior adventures they’d gone on.

This one tries it somewhere in the middle and, as a result, it seems real odd that they wouldn’t have already been introduced to Mustang at this point. It feels less like filler and more like filibuster in a show that’s already seeming a little aimless in comparison to sharp mega-arc conspiracy focus that the other version hit right away, I've got to say.

Watch this episode, "Dash! Automail” here and decide for yourself, then read my comments on the previous episode here.

Tom Pinchuk’s a writer and personality with a large number of comics, videos and features like this to his credit. Visit his website - - tompinchuk.com - - and follow his Twitter: @tompinchuk

Post by rubberluffy (596 posts) See mini bio Level 16

This little story is in the manga (chapter 4), but Brotherhood skipped over it entirely. Why? Because it's not very interesting. In the manga they use it to introduce Mustang's character, and Hughes doesn't show up in it at all. FMAB introduced both of them in the first episode (which was technically filler), so skipping this whole chapter was a good idea.

And I can't remember how it happens in this version, but in the manga Ed takes care of the problem quickly and easily. They also already know Mustang, too.

Post by ComicMan24 (8,759 posts) See mini bio Level 12

The first anime does a better job imo in showing us how Hughes became important to the boys.

Top Editors
Top Posters
NickTapalansky
12 posts
zaldar
11 posts
sickVisionz
11 posts
AgentJ
9 posts
sotyfan16
9 posts
FoxxFireArt
8 posts
Kino88
7 posts
Destinyheroknight
5 posts
CharredKnight
4 posts
DBZ_universe
4 posts
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel