Scenario 1: Nagato(healthy) vs 5 Kage
Scenario 2: Six Paths of Pain vs 5 Kage
Distance: 50 meters apart
Ahh, I thought this said Naruto.
I think Nagato loses both. Healthy Nagato hasn't done anything to impress me. He got his ass kicked quickly and promptly when he was a healthy infinite chakra non-crippled zombie and his only pre-Zombie healthy feats are beating up a bunch of crappy scrub level ninjas while failing to actually do anything to the one strong ninja that was there (Hanzo battle where Nagato's homeboy died)
I don't think the Six Paths could do anything against the Kages either. Almost all of them got solo'd by Sage Mode Naruto and I'd rate all of the Kage combined to be stronger than that.
@taichokage: How can they counter his summons? Or survive a Chou Shinra Tensei? Or his Gedo Mazo? Divine Attractor and Asura path with Human path could capture anyone of the kage then Nagato could keep away the rest with ST and summons. The only real threat here is Onoki every one else would pretty much die. I pretty much only think in round 1 Nagato can with Gedo Mazo with high difficulty. Round 2 he would lose mid difficulty.