" As for the battle I would say Broly should win for various reasons:Well said and accurate as always.
Strength: In terms of physical strength I have to put Green Scar above Broly simply because Broly has no strength feats that compare to the feats of the Hulk. Ordinary Savage Hulk managed to support the weight of a 150 billion ton mountain on his back while using his arm strength as well and Green Scar is a clearly more physically powerful version being able to lift far in the excess of 100 tons in an emotionally calm state while the regular Savage Hulk is at somewhere between 70-80 tons in a calm emotional state. Regular Hulk also managed to fight Thor blow to blow whilst the Asgardian God what is in his "Warrior's Madness" state where his already massive physical strength is amplified tenfold, managed to destroy an asteroid twice the size of Planet Earth, his physical power has allowed him to overcome an energy field powerful enough to change the orbit of a planet, crack the armor of Onslaught whereas even the Unstoppable Juggernaut failed and even destroy a powerful device specifically designed to destroy the Celestials, overwhelm even Hercules using pure physical strength and single handedly defeat a powerful roster of the X-Men. And those feats of strength were done by regular Savage Hulk and since Green Scar is the version involved it should be noted that he is much more powerful than the normal version of the Hulk. Now a look at Broly's physical power. Broly's physical strength alone allowed him to effortlessly dominate a Full Powered Super Saiyan Goku, Full Powered Super Saiyan Gohan, Super Trunks, Super Vegeta and Piccolo (Who was powerful enough to dominate even Android 17 who in respect is more powerful than an untrained Super Saiyan) as well as creating gigantic craters with powerful blows and causing the ground quake somewhat with simple steps however despite all of this Green Scar is the superior in terms of physical raw strength.
Speed: Green Scar's weakness falls here. Green Scar has a massive lack of speed whereas Broly dominates in this category. Broly has been shown to be sufficiently fast enough to easily dodge quick flurries of punches and kicks launched simultaneously by Piccolo and Goku and it should be noted that Broly had his arms crossed during the moment and had a relaxed facial expression clearly implying he was effortlessly dodging their attacks. Not to mention he overwhelmed his opponents with his incredible speed and even more so he managed to travel from galaxy to galaxy in less than a day whereas it takes light thousands of years to reach even the nearest galaxy. Broly should be fast enough that he can dodge every single one of the Hulk's strikes.
Flight: Broly has a large advantage due to his flight ability whereas the Hulk is a grounded brick. Broly can simply remain airborne and launch a barrage of planet-busting energy blasts at the Hulk until he either dies or is knocked unconscious.
Durability: Regular Hulk was capable of withstanding the Human Torch's Nova Blast without sustaining injury which is approximately the temperature of the Sun, withstand solar temperatures, a nuclear explosion at blank point range and survive planet-splitting attacks barely and Green Scar was visibly harmed by Sentry's Fire Tornado that ravaged much of Manhattan during the events of World War Hulk. Broly however has been shown to withstand countless hits by Goku, Gohan, Vegeta, Trunks and Piccolo without sustaining injury in the very least he was visibly relaxed and unfazed. Even more so he managed to effortlessly withstand a full powered Kamehameha by Full Powered Super Saiyan Goku at blank point range without fazing and sustaining no visible injury and this is most likely as the Warp Kamehameha used on Perfect Cell who commented on the power of the blast stating that if Goku pointed it towards the Earth then the planet itself would be destroyed. Even after being defeated by the combined power of Gohan, Piccolo, Trunks, Vegeta and Goku that was imbued within Goku who delivered a powerful blow to the area where Broly was stabbed as an infant he managed to survive even after crash landing on Earth (Which is seen in Broly: Second Coming). Also when Broly's father Paragus attempted to abandon his son to die on the ravaged planet due the approaching asteroid Broly killed his father and stated that he was foolish to think that he (Broly) would die simply because of the planet's destruction meaning that he could withstand planet-busting attacks with relative ease and it might have implied that he most likely survived a planet busting attack before in the past.
Stamina: While Green Scar possesses the stamina of the Hulk that has allowed the creature to fight for days before fatigue makes an impact on his body however Broly's stamina seemed to be limitless during his entire appearance in Dragon Ball Z however this could be due to the fact that he never fought against an opponent he needed to exert himself with.
Energy Projection: Green Scar during the closing end of World War Hulk began generating sufficient radiation that was capable of ravaging the entire city he was fighting in and the energy released from his mere steps managed to cause the city to quake and shake violently as well as destroy the Eastern Seaboard and he even stated that if he wasn't stopped soon he would eventually destroy the planet however this clearly would take some time to achieve. However Broly dominates this category with no question. Broly managed to effortlessly destroy an entire planet with an energy ball the size of his mere palm clearly showing how powerful the legendary Saiyan is. During the opening scenes of the first Broly movie one can clearly see the South Galaxy being destroyed and nearly vaporized by Broly's attack meaning he is either nearing or has become a planet-buster and it should be noted that at the time his power was being restrained by the device on his forehead that controlled him meaning that Broly's true power whilst in his Legendary Super Saiyan form is truly tremendous and freakish and it cannot be determined what kind of limit it might have. With the amount of power he houses Broly should be capable of completely vaporizing the Hulk from existence by projecting the sufficient energy in the form of a blast, wave etc. since he could apparently bring great destruction to an entire galaxy whilst his power was being heavily restrained. Broly's power was also sufficient enough that he was overpowering a Family Kamehameha launched by Goku, Gohan and Goten who were all in Super Saiyan forms and it should be noted that Broly was using a single arm to overpower their attack and it was not until Trunks created a barrier around Broly's attack preventing the Saiyan from adding more energy to his attack that the trio managed to kill him.
Force Fields/Energy Barriers: Broly has been seen creating spherical energy barriers around himself that grant him protection. These barriers were powerful enough to briefly protect him from a Family Kamehameha launched by Goku, Gohan and Goten until the barrier quickly shattered from the attack's power.
Healing Factor: Both fighters have impressive healing factors as regular Hulk's healing factor allowed him to regenerate in mere minutes after having his a large portion of his muscle mass and skin removed from his body. Broly's healing factor is so high that his power allowed him to return from death after being stabbed and left for dead as a mere baby.
Fighting Skill: Unlike most of the Hulk's incarnations Green Scar is in actuality an expert warrior having meditated and trained intensely during his time in Sakaar and has become proficient in the use of swords and axes. His fighting skill has become that of a highly dangerous warrior and he has mastered unique alien fighting styles never seen before however during the events of World War Hulk it was seen that it was possible to enraged him enough that he loses all rationality and begins to border insanity. Broly's fighting style resembles wrestling as he was constantly seen using clotheslines, pile-drivers etc. his fighting style is further observed to be designed to inflict pain and suffering rather than using killing blows as he constantly used moves and attacks designed to cripple, break backs, break bones and dislocate his opponent's arms etc. rather than killing them instantly. However Broly's punches have been shown to deliver a tremendous amount of damage as he also uses a slight heavy-hitting style. He was also seen constantly smashing his opponent's body and ramming their heads into walls and crushing them accordingly. Broly's fighting skill might have been limited. Paragus was apparently not a high class warrior and must have possessed limited combat skill however it could be assumed that he did teach Broly how to fight as limited as his teachings may be.
Tactics and Strategies: Green Scar is a much smarter and tactical opponent than Broly due to the Hulk and Bruce Banner working together whereas Broly is an insane psychopath who almost never plans out his attacks and simply uses brute force. Overall Broly should win as he could simply rely on his speed, flight and energy projection. He could use his speed to simply dodge the Hulk's attacks or either use his flight to remain airborne and simply launch a powerful enough energy attack that would obliterate or knock the Hulk unconscious. ND "
Savage hulk can tank and is a planet buster (with his fists) but dispite that and the green scar beign stronger then the savage hulk Broly still wins i am pretty sure broly is stronger and like uhlk would get stronger the longer the fight goes on. now if it was World breaker Hulk i'de say hulk could win depending on how the writter dipicts broly using his speed advantage but scence its just WWH broly wins 10/10.
" @Gazzly said:
" Hulk stomps "WARNING: the above statement contains epic fail. When Hulk survives a galaxy buster attack, let me know. Note: No offense meant at all."