You know it's not a good match when you have to nerf one combatant.
Anyways, it's pretty much what DHK says, Black Star easily still. BS is more durable, has better destructive force, better CQC fighter, and has techs that could one shot Elric. Even though speed is equalized BS is still far more agile as well. Ed is just outclassed here.
Yeah. Ed is only dangerous at very close range against someone who isn't faster. His longer range abilities are easily avoided by faster opponents and the same goes for close range. Ed realistically can't beat anyone with superhuman stats of practically any degree as long as they are serious.