My choices for Summer 2011 - Week 1

Topic started by matti00 on July 14, 2011. Last post by zaldar 3 years ago.
Post by matti00 (28 posts) See mini bio Level 7

Usagi Drop (Bunny Drop) #1

I find it very easy to like this show. The story of a man who takes it upon himself to look after his late grandfathers illegitimate daughter – and therefore his aunt – despite being wildly unprepared for any such undertaking, this first episode oozes charm from every orifice, from the characters, to the dialogue, to the art style.

Right from the beginning, the art style demands your attention as it is so strikingly appealing. You can see above that all the backgrounds appear to be hand painted, and it looks incredible. It’s a good thing the first few minutes didn’t really have anything happening in them, as I used that time just admiring the art.

Once you get into the meat of the story, however, it becomes clear there is more to this than just a pretty face. The subject matter for this first episode is uncharacteristically heavy, with the task at hand of preparing the grandfathers body for his funeral taking a back seat to deciding what to do with this child who has bought shame upon their family.

I won’t go into too much detail, but I will say that this was a very heartwarming first episode. If they can make me feel this invested from the get go, I look forward to seeing where they take it, as well as more on how the two main characters interact. They are very likable, and I have very high hopes for Usagi Drop and its makeshift family.

The iDOLM@STER #1

Admittedly, I’ve never played extremely popular (to someone) iDOLM@STER games for the Xbox 360. It’s something that’s just scrolled past as I browsed the Xbox Live Marketplace, and the only thought I gave it was “That’s a weird name for a game”. I am interested to see what all the fuss is about though, but as buying a Japanese Xbox isn’t really an option for someone on part time wages (recession y’all), this will have to do for now.

With my confession out of the way, you can take it however you will that I don’t really get this show. For the first episode at least, it’s essentially set up like a documentary, with the producer asking questions about their Idol lifestyle, and the girls answering candidly. This is by no means a bad idea, as it’s an interesting way to tackle the problem of transferring the game to a series. The problem I have is that the questions aren’t voiced; they’re spelled out at the bottom of the screen. I don’t really have a valid explanation for it, but this coupled with the video lens effect on the screen makes me feel really voyeuristic and creepy. I think I’d feel embarrassed if someone saw me watching this show, and that can’t be a good thing.

The characters are all your typical anime stereotypes, the hyper one, the lazy one, the early developer, the tomboy, etc. The characters all interact with each other in a believable way, and despite the large number of them on screen at any one time, it never feels like any of them are just standing there with nothing to do, which has to be some kind of miracle. The thing is, in trying to introduce each character within the confines of a 23 minute show, none of them really get much screen time, leaving them all largely forgettable and me largely bamboozled.

While I may have complained a bit about The iDOLM@STER, the caveat to this is that these are all issues that could disappear beyond the first episode. It’s difficult to know exactly what this show is at this stage. I thought it was going to be a show similar to Azumanga Daioh to begin with (throw a bunch of characters together, watch the fireworks), but the introduction of a male lead at the end of the episode means this could just as easily be a standard harem show. There are way too many variables, which is largely why I’m willing to give this show a second and third chance.

Finally…

As I mentioned earlier, I’m only working a part time job at the moment, so I’m going to try and do some of this once a week. It is my first time doing something like this though, so if you have any opinions, corrections or feedback (positive or negative), please let me know. I really would be happy to know how you think I’m doing!

Post by Gaff (213 posts) See mini bio Level 11

On IdolM@ster:

From what I know about the franchise, the text-only questions are a direct reference to the games themselves: the player / viewer assuming the role of the faceless and voiceless Producer in the games. So, "here's one for the fans!", a little bit of service, right there.

I agree about the lazy characterization: stereotypes (lazy / ditzy / busty / serious) and motivations (money, self-discovery, dreams) does not make for great characters, but it's going to be very hard to cram 6 years of videogame backstory in 12 episodes.

Then again... At least they're not trying to kill each other in giant mechs.

Post by matti00 (28 posts) See mini bio Level 7

Should have mentioned, I get why they do the text-only questions, but it still creeps me out.

I think the fact that it's only 12 episodes tells me that they want to set this up for a long running series. More power to them, I hope they get to develop the characters a bit more within the confines of the anime. If they do it right, it could be really successful.

...and it will make a lot more sense than big ass f**king mechs.

Post by AURON570 (552 posts) See mini bio Level 15
you get a high five from me for using "bamboozled". :)
Post by zaldar (1,237 posts) See mini bio Level 15
I personally like the big mechs more myself...and from philosophy and technology they made sense.  In fifty or so years i expect something like that would be possible to be made.  Not a big fan of the hand drawn watercolor like look of bunny drop either.  I do hope it makes the case the girl is not the one at fault and so should be treated like any other child.  A non loli, non harem, cute show would be  nice.
 
Idolmaster I have no interest in at all.  Looks like the shows you won't be watching will be the ones I will be heh.  Ah well.  
 c C
Out of curiosity which were your favorite shows this last season?   C and Steins Gate are mine.
Post by matti00 (28 posts) See mini bio Level 7

@zaldar said:

Out of curiosity which were your favorite shows this last season? C and Steins Gate are mine.

Watched/watching Denpa Onna To Seishun Otoko, Hanasaku Iroha, and a bit of Blue Exorcist. I came to IS: Infinite Stratos a bit late too so I'll include that. I'm a bit of an oddity, in that I'm a man that doesn't really like shounen, but loves slice of life, harem and romance. I've been trying to get more into it but Blue Exorcist didn't really grab me. Steins Gate did look really good though, so I'm gonna put that on my official to-do list, which probably means I'll never watch it now knowing me!

@AURON570 said:

you get a high five from me for using "bamboozled". :)

Watch iDOLM@STER and you'll understand! Being English I have a tendancy to sometimes use flamboyant language.

Post by zaldar (1,237 posts) See mini bio Level 15
Ah interesting shows I didn't have any interest in at all.  I really wouldn't call C shonen as it really is more than just simple shonen like bleach and such.  Steins gate has some romance and harem parts to it.  Be interested to see what you think of the other shows.  So far for me Bunny drop and the one with the girl pioliting a mech are the only ones that strike me as interesting at all.
Top Editors
Top Posters
zaldar
2 posts
matti00
2 posts
Gaff
1 posts
AURON570
1 posts
rubberluffy
1 posts
Elfenlied1012
1 posts
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel