First Date: Black Butler Volume 1

Topic started by gia on Feb. 7, 2010. Last post by Aesc 4 years, 7 months ago.
Post by gia (3,032 posts) See mini bio Level 13
Post by Zeouterlimits (516 posts) See mini bio Level 7
2 of my close female friends love Kuroshitsuji... 
  Perhaps I'll check it out... I don't know.
Post by FLStyle (423 posts) See mini bio Level 12
But could he out-butler the butler from Saki?
Post by kippy666 (7 posts) See mini bio Level 1
I loved the anime, and I went crazy when I brought the manga! It was really good!
The three guy aren't that bad, besides they are there for a reason, well in the anime they were anyway...maybe, probably. lol
Post by gia (3,032 posts) See mini bio Level 13
@FLStyle: I vote "yes." :D 
 
@kippy666: We'll see!
Post by Lan (621 posts) See mini bio Level 13
I iz jeelous. I really enjoyed the anime and have been waiting for the manga to be released in book form. Black Butler isn't necessarily a misnomer...the obvious reason is Sebastian's black hair and clothes :P; more than likely refers to Sebastian's true identity.
 
I always found the three idiot servants hilarious and <3 Tanaka (old butler/head of the servants guy). Although I know the anime differs a lot from the manga, I would hope that the purpose of the servants being there is still the same. Believe me, there is PLENTY of slash fic and fanart out there.
Post by JackSukeru (402 posts) See mini bio Level 8
Aw, don't beat yourself up about it Gia,
Bard looks like his specific character trait is being forgettable. 
 
In any case my interest for this is a solid 3/5 atm, maybe I'll check it out. Later.
Post by gia (3,032 posts) See mini bio Level 13
@RockmanBionics: FWIW, if I was giving a number to it right now, I'd give it a 4 of 5. It's just missing something to nudge it into that solid 5.
Post by Kris (130 posts) See mini bio Level 7
It's difficult to describe why I love this series so much.
But a translation note: even though they explained why in the back of the book, the "I'm a devil of a butler" thing just didn't sit right with me.  That may be a more accurate translation, but when I was watching the anime, someone translated it as "one hell of a butler," which...sounds better and makes more sense, in my opinion.
 
I don't know what the exact translation of Kuroshitsuji is, but as someone said...  Black Butler because he's a dark character and wears black...I guess.
 
And obviously those who have seen the anime (or read ahead in the manga) know that the three (four) servants are there for good reason.  Though of course, without that knowledge, they do indeed appear rather worthless.
 
For a first volume, it probably is a little weak.  The servants appear to be useless comedic fluff, the nature of Ciel and Sebastian's relationship is not actually explained (in regards to WHY they have a contract), and there's no sign of the central plot line to be found.  I imagine a lot of the sales are from people who are already fans (like me), though I admit I am rather surprised there are so many fans.  There is a lot to love there, though.  There's an element of effortless humor that colors the story quite nicely.
Post by gia (3,032 posts) See mini bio Level 13
@Kris: That's fair, and I'm with you on the "hell of a butler" translation. I had other notes that I could have made-- there were a couple of random moments where they went with a sort of old-fashioned speech. It was Mey Rin (an odd romanization since it reads like fakey Chinese-- Mei Lin?), talking to Elizabeth in the second chapter. She says "I can see nary a thing without my glasses," while Elizabeth is running around squealing "CUUUUTE!" about things. It was a little odd. 
 
Kuroshitsuji does translate directly to "Black Butler," I just continue to have this mental image of someone seeing ONLY the title on the side of the book while it's on a shelf and being confused ;)
Post by Kris (130 posts) See mini bio Level 7
@gia
I was thinking, and I do have this to say about the servants:
There's no way a character like Sebastian, who is all about appearance and perfection, would ever let truly useless people like that work in the manor.  That should be enough for someone to pick up that there must be something about them, even if we don't know what it is yet.  Just a thought.
 
I did think the old fashioned speech slipping in there was a little odd, but it came across (to me) as being done on purpose to seem silly or comedic.  As if she was trying to sound more elegant on purpose, as a character, while talking to Elizabeth...maybe. Maybe I'm stretching that a bit.  :)
 
But then, this is Victorian England...and there's a character basically carting around a cell phone, and it appears that Ciel enjoys playing video games.  So there are several strange things.
Post by JackSukeru (402 posts) See mini bio Level 8
@gia: Well I was talking more about my interest in reading it based on what I now know, which isn't much. 
 
I checked to see if I could import it which was no problem, but as of now I'm thinking of holding off for awhile and then getting a few volumes at the same time to try it out :)
Post by AtomoPanda (26 posts) See mini bio Level 6

Kuroshitsuji !!!!! 
I LOVE IT!!!!  
The maid, chef, and gardner actually have a inportant role in the next few books 
just leting you knw    
Post by John_Martone (2,992 posts) See mini bio Level 10
@FLStyle said:
" But could he out-butler the butler from Saki? "
I was about to say that the butler from Saki needed a spin off... but then again, that butler very well could have been the black butler. 
 
Now, I'm just imaging that stuck up blonde getting the butler from a pact with satan.
Post by Aesc (2 posts) See mini bio Level 3
"It's not as solid as I would've expected", I could say the same thing about the publisher.
Top Editors
Top Posters
gia
4 posts
Kris
2 posts
JackSukeru
2 posts
Nebs
1 posts
Aesc
1 posts
John_Martone
1 posts
Zeouterlimits
1 posts
FLStyle
1 posts
kippy666
1 posts
Lan
1 posts
Mandatory Network

Submissions can take several hours to be approved.

Save ChangesCancel